I taped these two movies last month off TCM for later viewing and finally got to them this week. I originally taped them for Van Johnson and Spencer Tracy.
I wasn't sure what I would think of Plymouth Adventure (1952). Many times, historically based films are changed to make them more dramatic and appealing to viewers. I was surprised at how realistic it was. THe ship was cramped, as one would expect, there was disease and death, but also joy and new life, in just a few months. There were storms that seemed very realistic to me (although, I've never been on a boat, or on a boat in a storm). I didn't really like Spencer Tracy's character (Captain Jones) at first, but I guess the viewers were not supposed to like him until the end when he sort of redeems himself. I thought Van Johnson's part (John Alden) was great, but he got into a lot of fights with the sailors. He was protecting Dawn Addams from the sailors leering. This was the first film of Gene Tierney's I've ever seen. Now I know why she's so beloved. She was beautiful and had an elegant air about her. I enjoyed her performance, but her character was sad. Overall, I thought it was a very good film. I laughed a little and even cried a little, probably the most because of little William Button. Poor kid. Anyway, I would definitely recommend this film to anyone.
I had been looking forward to Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo (1944) for a long time. I knew it was supposed to be a great war film with Tracy and Johnson again and with Robert Walker, whose work I'v erecently come to really appreciate. It was not a disappointment. I was kept in suspence for most of the film and really felt for the characters. I thought Tracy's part was a bit stiff, but he was probably supposed to be since it was based on a true story. I initially thought the movie would end in tragedy, but was pleased with the ending. I thought Van Johnson was brilliant in this role (of course, he usually is). I was hooked from the very beginning. The flashbacks when he was sleeping or knocked out were a great way to show his strong relationship with his newly wedded wife. Not only was this film suspenseful, but it had it's light funny moments as well. Robert Walker's small-town shy character was funny as well as some of the others. I thought it was an awesome film, one of, if not, the best war film I've seen.